In the wake of the illegal murder of Cecil, the Zimbabwe
lion who now has greater worldwide name recognition than Taylor Swift or anyone
running for U.S. president, I have seen postings on social media wondering why
the killing of an animal far, far away has caused more outrage than the murder
of Sandra Bland, the latest (one of the latest is more accurate, since another
incident happened last week in Cincinnati) unarmed African American person to
be killed by police or in police custody. She was found dead on July 13 in a
Texas jail cell she probably had no cause to be in after a routine traffic
stop. There certainly was outrage from the American public about yet another
police-related death, yet less than two weeks later, Cecil’s death was all
anyone could talk about.
I have sympathy for those who are suggesting that racism or
perhaps just apathy are to blame for the fact that Cecil is outpolling Sandra.
After all, what is happening between police and black people in America these
days is scary and indicative of a larger pattern of police brutality. According
to a recent study by The Guardian
newspaper:
- U.S. police fatally shot
more people in the first 24 days of 2015 than England and Wales police
have in the last 24 years, combined.
- In Australia, there were
94 fatal police shootings between 1992 and 2011. In the U.S., there were
97 fatal police shootings in March 2015.
- Black Americans are more
than twice as likely to be unarmed when killed during encounters with
police as white people.
- Some 140 black Americans
have been killed by police this year.
Obviously this is abhorrent. And yet I would also suggest
that the sheer volume of black lives not mattering to police is part of the
problem. After awhile, news fatigue sets in. Who can remember the names of all
the victims, aside from those most widely covered, such as Michael Brown, Eric
Garner, and Walter Scott? We as a public accept that there is a problem but we
have become numbed to it. There is no more shock value; we perhaps even come to
expect it. I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if there aren’t one or two
more black victims before this summer ends.
Furthermore, the media is always in search of a new story,
especially a new shocking story (you can’t read an article about Cecil without
being reminded that he was decapitated and skinned), and, of course, everyone
likes a good animal story, right? I count myself among those who are outraged
by Cecil’s murder. I also count myself among those who are outraged that our
police are executing Americans in numbers one would only expect in some
dystopian science fiction society – and particularly that African Americans
still are targeted by and vulnerable to the white American power structures.
So where is my outrage? It’s in both places, and not for
dissimilar reasons. There’s too much gun violence and too little respect for
life. And it’s not just happening here, and so my outrage is not confined to
these two matters. Just yesterday, an Ultra-Orthodox Jew stabbed six people
marching in a Gay Pride parade in Jerusalem (which, incidentally – or
ironically – means “city of peace”). As a Jew, I am outraged that the
supposedly most pious of my religion could act in such a way that is so counter
to the “Jewish values” that were drummed into me in Sunday School.
For that matter, I have long been outraged by the Israeli
government, especially Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who arrogantly
continues to build settlements in disputed areas and throws obstacle upon
obstacle on the road to peace. China with its endless human rights abuses has
always outraged me. Closer to home, Donald Trump outrages me, as does just
about every Republican office holder in the country, all of whom are hateful
obstructionists, most of whom are horribly racist, and none of whom give a shit
about women.
The IRS outrages me. I’m sure I get many more notices from
them than does, say, Apple Computer, which pays next to nothing in taxes,
despite earning quite a few more billion dollars per year than I do. Reality
television outrages me. Last winter outraged me. Roger Goodell outrages me. In
fact, I’m going to repeat that last one. Roger Fucking Goodell outrages me.
Now, none of the last few outrages are on the same level as
poaching a protected animal or murdering unarmed black people, but for those
who wonder where our outrage is, it’s everywhere. There’s so much to be pissed
off about. We can’t be outraged about one thing; even if it’s a horrific thing,
it’s one of many horrific things going on in our neighborhoods, our country,
and our world. This very evening, my ex-wife, a social worker who works in the
labor and delivery department of a local hospital, told me that a barefoot woman
walked in, six centimeters dilated, ready to give birth, and she couldn’t tell
people where she lived, how she got there, who the father was, and whether or
not this was her first pregnancy. Eventually, she was able to give her name but
still much is not known. She had scabies but gave birth to a healthy boy – a baby
that is likely going straight into the system.
One could be outraged at this woman, but this woman is a
victim of the system as well. Where were the mental health services she needed?
The obstetric services? Has she been living on the street? Can you imagine a
homeless pregnant woman fending for herself in the richest country on earth? If
that doesn’t make you outraged, I don’t know what will.
So yes, I am outraged. I’m outraged at all of it. And frankly, the thing I’m probably most outraged about is that I don’t know what to do about it.
So yes, I am outraged. I’m outraged at all of it. And frankly, the thing I’m probably most outraged about is that I don’t know what to do about it.